(picture taken from Goodreads;
cover art by Kekai Kotaki;
book design by Stephanie Moss)
book design by Stephanie Moss)
First Impression: This
is a really great story idea, but I'm not sure I like the actual book. Dashner is trying to do
too many things at once, and the ideas aren't quite cohesive. Also, I don't like the psychological and emotional aspects of the characters. Why does Michael feel ashamed about his anger when he thinks he's being kidnapped? That seems like a normal reaction to me. And why is all of the emotion in this book so fleeting? Is it poor writing, or is that just how the author perceives adolescence?
Conclusion: I
guess I'm not a big fan of Dashner's writing style, although this is
the only book I've read by him, so it's hard to compare. The characters in this one were flat and contradictory. For example, Michael is supposed to be the most responsible of the three main characters, but as soon as the action really gets going, he's the one verbally attacking everyone they meet and generally being difficult. Also, the ending was horrible. I guess Dashner made the decisions that he did so he could continue the series on a certain path, but it pushed me even farther away from characters I cared little about to begin with. I almost
feel bad for not liking it, because he obviously enjoyed writing it (my
assumption based on his appreciation notes at the end of the book). But,
so it is. I just didn't feel any
connection to this book by the end. I probably won't read anything else he writes.
Recommendation: The people I know who liked this book were fans of Dashner before, so if you've read any of his other books and enjoy his writing style, here's some more.